Hello Jeremy,
Once the objects are similar except for their titles, you can treat them as one mapped object. When selecting the properties to be used as identification attributes along with the other suggested properties, you may select the WindowTitle property and specify the * wildcard as its value (just as you supposed). As an alternative, you may enable the
conditional mode of the name mapping and specify both of the possible titles (e.g. WindowTitle="Name1" OR WindowTitle="Name1").
After that, to determine which of the objects was mapped, you just need to verify the actual value of the WindowTitle property.
Keep in mind that when both of the mapped objects are available simultaneously, only one of them would be accessible by the mapped name.
Regards.