I think that is happening because it looks to me like the stop part of Stop and Rerun isn't an actual stop of the test. It's more like a pause and retry.
https://support.smartbear.com/testcomplete/docs/testing-with/running/control-test-flow/stop-and-rerun.html
If a retry passes successfully or with warnings, TestComplete will mark this test item as successful or warning respectively and add info about the number of retries to the Summary report.
If all rerun attempts fail, TestComplete will mark the test item as failed and proceed with the next test item.
Do you want it to retry and then eventually stop the whole test or retry and eventually keep going?
