mock service is cycling through responses despite being different requests

So I see what you are describing on dispatch criteria.  

SOAP UI is still very new to me and functionality is not obvious. 

My initial impression on what SOAP UI mock service would do is if I have a request with specific data, then I would receive the response that is associated to the respective request.  

In reviewing this tutorial, I saw exactly what are you talking about dispatch criteria. 

https://www.soapui.org/tutorials/web-service-sample-project.html

But number 6 does not go into detail on how to do what my initial impression above.  

I then found this link that described dispatching in little detail. 

https://www.soapui.org/soap-mocking/mockoperations-and-responses.html

I tried to follow the pattern shown on this page for query-match. 

I think I am close to what I need.  

But when I add a second request, I click Play after submitting a request with new data, I get this:

But I expect to see response 2.  

Thoughts on what I am doing incorrectly?