Path parameter always gives default response

I am testing various responses from a REST API by configuring different values of path parameter in Ready API service

While testing this with local Jetty server it works perfectly. I can get both the responses I configured by passing appropriate parameter value in request. But when I deploy this on server and send any request, it only returns default response I configured in the API.

Not sure why this is happening with only PATH/TEMPLATE parameter type. I never faced issue with header or query parameter. 

Any hint if I am doing something wrong here or any other way, we can test path parameter responses from Ready API?