QueryParameters not added to URL when using testRunner.sh

Hi,

I'm not able to reproduce this.
Using SoapUI Pro 4.6.1 the query params are in the url when running testrunner.bat from the command line:

11:41:15,327 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClient
Connection] Sending request: POST /maps/api/place/add/json?sensor=true&key=AIzaS
yDW7PImhqPGJD05Qa9bEu HTTP/1.1
11:41:15,947 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClient
Connection] Receiving response: HTTP/1.1 200 OK
11:41:15,957 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Connection can be kept a
live indefinitely
11:41:16,037 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] Finished running SoapUI testcase [J
son TestCase], time taken: 1243ms, status: FINISHED

Can you attach your project, and check <SoapUI install>\bin for error logs?

Hi
Thanks for the fast response.

I will try to minimize the project and then send it to you.

Meanwhile:
This is the output when running in SoapUI:
Thu Oct 31 15:08:35 CET 2013:DEBUG:Sending request: GET /v10/carLocator.do HTTP/1.1
Thu Oct 31 15:08:35 CET 2013:DEBUG:Receiving response: HTTP/1.1 200 OK
Thu Oct 31 15:08:35 CET 2013:DEBUG:Connection can be kept alive indefinitely
Thu Oct 31 15:08:35 CET 2013:DEBUG:Stale connection check
Thu Oct 31 15:08:35 CET 2013:DEBUG:Attempt 1 to execute request
Thu Oct 31 15:08:35 CET 2013:DEBUG:Sending request: GET /customerapi/rest/v3.0/vehicles/SOAP2030874909256/position?client_latitude=50.05078&client_accuracy=1&client_longitude=9.07546 HTTP/1.1

And this is the output when running using testrunner.sh:
17:08:30,606 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClientConnection] Sending request: GET /v10/carLocator.do HTTP/1.1
17:08:30,609 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClientConnection] Receiving response: HTTP/1.1 200 OK
17:08:30,609 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Connection can be kept alive indefinitely
17:08:30,670 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] Assertion [Script Assertion] has status VALID
17:08:30,671 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] running step [GetPosition - distance check true]
17:08:30,689 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Stale connection check
17:08:30,694 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Attempt 1 to execute request
17:08:30,694 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClientConnection] Sending request: GET /customerapi/rest/v3.0/vehicles/SOAP3747452760855/position HTTP/1.1

The SOAP.... part of the URL is generated every time so it should be unique.

/Regards Pontus

Hi
Attached is the composite project as a zip.
I had to remove a lot of properitary stuff from the project, but at least you should be able to open it and run it.
Unzip project.zip and open it.

Output when running in SOAPUI:
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Attempt 1 to execute request
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Sending request: GET /customerapi/rest/v2.0/vehicles/SOAP5867537382424/position?client_latitude=57.651165&client_accuracy=10&client_longitude=11.864204 HTTP/1.1
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Receiving response: HTTP/1.1 401 Unauthorized
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Connection can be kept alive indefinitely
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Target requested authentication
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Authorization challenge processed
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Authentication scope: BASIC 'Spring Security Application'@localhost:8080
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Credentials not found
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:INFO:Got response for [Volvo Connect.GetPositionUsingTestCaseVin:REST Test Request] in 60ms (1135 bytes)
Thu Oct 31 17:52:48 CET 2013:DEBUG:Connection closed

Output when runnig from commandline:
pontus@pontus-VirtualBox ~/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0/bin $ ./testrunner.sh -sCarLocator -c"Car Locator - distance check on/off - VOC-TC-469" -R"TestSuite Report" /home/pontus/Documents/soapui/================================
=
= SOAPUI_HOME = /home/pontus/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0
=
================================
soapUI Pro 4.6.0 TestCase Runner
Configuring log4j from [/home/pontus/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0/bin/soapui-log4j.xml]
17:51:45,139 INFO [SoapUI] Adding [/home/pontus/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0/bin/ext/scripts-3.15.1-SNAPSHOT.jar] to extensions classpath
17:51:45,147 INFO [SoapUI] Adding [/home/pontus/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0/bin/ext/json-lib-2.4-jdk15.jar] to extensions classpath
17:51:45,150 INFO [SoapUI] Adding [/home/pontus/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0/bin/ext/ojdbc6-11.2.0.1.0.jar] to extensions classpath
17:51:45,862 INFO [DefaultSoapUICore] initialized soapui-settings from [/home/pontus/soapui-settings.xml]
17:51:46,699 WARN [SoapUIProGroovyScriptEngineFactory] Missing scripts folder [/home/pontus/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0/scripts]
17:51:46,700 INFO [DefaultSoapUICore] Adding listeners from [/home/pontus/voc/tools/soapui-pro-4.6.0/bin/listeners/demo-listeners.xml]
17:51:49,043 INFO [WsdlProject] Loaded project from [file:/home/pontus/Documents/soapui/]
17:51:50,005 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] Running soapUI tests in project [Volvo Connect_RemoteServices]
17:51:50,053 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] Running TestCase [Car Locator - distance check on/off - VOC-TC-469]
17:51:50,092 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] Running soapUI testcase [Car Locator - distance check on/off - VOC-TC-469]
17:51:50,106 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] running step [REST Test Request]
17:51:50,305 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Attempt 1 to execute request
17:51:50,305 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClientConnection] Sending request: GET /customerapi/rest/v2.0/vehicles/SOAP5867537382424/position HTTP/1.1
17:51:50,374 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClientConnection] Receiving response: HTTP/1.1 401 Unauthorized
17:51:50,379 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Connection can be kept alive indefinitely
17:51:50,379 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Target requested authentication
17:51:50,382 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Authorization challenge processed
17:51:50,383 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Authentication scope: BASIC 'Spring Security Application'@localhost:8080
17:51:50,384 DEBUG [HttpClientSupport$SoapUIHttpClient] Credentials not found
17:51:50,552 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] Finished running soapUI testcase [Car Locator - distance check on/off - VOC-TC-469], time taken: 171ms, status: FINISHED
17:51:50,552 INFO [SoapUIProTestCaseRunner] TestCase [Car Locator - distance check on/off - VOC-TC-469] finished with status [FINISHED] in 171ms

/Regards Pontus

Hi,

I imported your project and noticed that the GetPositionUsingTestCaseVin - distance check resource doesn't have any query parameters in the body compared to GetPositionUsingTestCaseVin which has client_latitude,client_accuracy, and client_longitude in the body. The REST Test Request test step does not have any query parameters in the body. You should add the query parameters for the * distance check request and try again.

Here is a reference on REST query parameters:
http://www.soapui.org/REST-Testing/unde ... eters.html

Hi
I got it to work, but I still thinks it is a bug and I don't have a solution for my problem yet.

It works the when the resource path for a REST request looks like:
/customerapi/rest/position

But when the resource path looks like(i.e. using project or testcase properties) it doesn't work:
/customerapi/rest/${#Project#API_VERSION}/vehicles/${#TestCase#VIN}/position

In our case we have 3 different API_VERSION and want to run the same test cases on all 3 api versions, thats why we have ${#Project#API_VERSION} in the URL.
And ${#TestCase#VIN} is generated in the begining of the testcase.

Is there any workaround for this?

/Rgards Pontus

Hi,

when you run your test case, you say that the resource params do not evaluate correctly. And you resource is defined as:
/customerapi/rest/${#Project#API_VERSION}/vehicles/${#TestCase#VIN}/position

So when you run the test case, can you double click on the run REST step in "TestCase Log" tab and look at what the URL is for the request in the 'Raw' Request tab. Does it have the API_VERSION and the VIN?

Or is it just:
<domain>/customerapi/rest//vehicles//position

Thanks,
Michael Giller
SmartBear Software

Hi
From my logs in earlier posts.
This is the soapui log when running the testcase in SOAPUI:
Thu Oct 31 17:52:17 CET 2013:DEBUG:Sending request: GET /customerapi/rest/v2.0/vehicles/SOAP5867537382424/position?client_latitude=57.651165&client_accuracy=10&client_longitude=11.864204 HTTP/1.1
Here is one property taken from the project and one property taken from the project.
The configured URL is:
/customerapi/rest/${#Project#API_VERSION}/vehicles/${#TestCase#VIN}/position
i.e ${#Project#API_VERSION} is set to v2.0 and ${#TestCase#VIN} is set to SOAP5867537382424

Here is the same log row when running the testcase with testrunner:
17:51:50,305 DEBUG [SoapUIMultiThreadedHttpConnectionManager$SoapUIDefaultClientConnection] Sending request: GET /customerapi/rest/v2.0/vehicles/SOAP5867537382424/position HTTP/1.1
And as you can see the parameters are missing.

Thanks again for the fast response. This issue is urgent for us becuase we are in the process of letting jenkins run all our regressions tests on a regular basis.
Regards Pontus

Hi,

I put this in my previous post:

I imported your project and noticed that the GetPositionUsingTestCaseVin - distance check resource doesn't have any query parameters in the body compared to GetPositionUsingTestCaseVin which has client_latitude,client_accuracy, and client_longitude in the body. The REST Test Request test step does not have any query parameters in the body. You should add the query parameters for the * distance check request and try again.

Have you looked at the GetPositionUsingTestCaseVin - distance check in SoapUI and noticed the missing query parameters in the body?

Hi
After trying to reproduce the problem with a smaller project and with my original project I have some good new and some bad news.
The good news, I got to it to work with the query parameters on the rest request. Both from inside SOAPUI and by using testrunner, the change I did was to rename of the restcall and not to include " " (spaces) in the names.

But then, the bad news, I had to restart my computer.
And the next time I opened my project in SOAPUI, It was not the same project as I saved before the restart. The changes I had made were not there.
I did the same changes again to my project, and made sure that I save the project. Everything worked well so far, both when running test from SOAPUI and testrunner.
But then I started to remove some unused rest calls from the test and saved project. The test worked fine when running in SOAPUI but stopped to work from testrunner. And the interesting thing here is that, then running from testrunner I sometimes get queryparameters on all my URL even on URLs that should not have query parameters. And sometimes I didn't get any queryParameters on any URLs.
I tried to do small changes in the project, make sure that test still worked when running from SOAPUI, and then saved the project and run the test using testrunner. And sometimes the changes did seem to be saved and picked up by testrunner, but sometime it looked like it was running with an old project.
Im very confused here, and this is a showstopper for us to continue use SOAPUI. We will start to look into other alternatives, but we have a lot of test and competence invested in SOAPUI and would be glad if we can continue to use SOAPUI and run our from commandline.

I know that my bug report looks very confused, but as I can not reproduce the same behaviour twice (and when I look into the soapui project files in disc they seem to contain a lot of information that I have removed from the project) you must give me instructions how I can help you to debug this and send you a better debug report.

As a developer I think the problem lies in how you save the project and loads it, and also maybe that you load the project in different ways depending on if gui if opening the project or if testrunner is opening the project.

Thanks, Pontus

Hi,

Please attach the SoapUI .log files located in <soapui install>\bin directory.

And to be clear, the problem with the query parameters not being present when running with testrunner is now resolved?

The current problem is the SoapUI project changes not being saved when you save it, and testrunner not picking up the changes all the time?


Also if you can attach your current project that would be helpful.


Regards,
Marcus
SmartBear Support