Forum Discussion

xxlyyk's avatar
xxlyyk
New Contributor
3 years ago

powershell from groovy no longer working

We have a powershell script to get something from a msmq queue. This used to run fine before readyapi 3.10 (I'm not totally sure which the latest version was that we tried before that(, but in 3.10 e...
TNeuschwanger's avatar
TNeuschwanger
Champion Level 2
3 years ago

Hello xxlyyk 

 

You need to help us help you...  "no longer working" does not help us to solve your issue...  Are you getting an error code response now that you didn't before?  Is the error code different than it used to be?  Is the directory not created when you run your script?  What indicates to us that it is not working?

 

I took the code you provided and ran it in SoapUI 5.6.0 and ReadyAPI 3.20.0...  Both versions returned exit value of 0.  SoapUI created the directory while ReadyAPI didn't.  Since you have a Powershell layer it is hard to debug why that might be the case and adds complexity to a simple operation.

 

My recommendation is to un-complicate your world and use the ReadyAPI features for handling JMS (message queues).  Eliminate PS as a dependency and do what you can using the built in Groovy.  The 8 lines of PS code you presented as a sample is easily reduced to 1 line in a Groovy test step:

new File('C:\\JSONJournal\\tests\\').mkdirs();

 

Complexity becomes expensive when you have to resort to debugging and whoever has to maintain that complexity in the future when you pass it along to the next person.

 

Regards,

Todd

  • xxlyyk's avatar
    xxlyyk
    New Contributor
    3 years ago
    Well you exactly recreated the behaviour I got, directory got created in
    old version and not in the new version. No error code, nothing. So
    basically you are confirming that this is a bug and not something weird in
    my environment (we reproduced the error in multiple of our own
    environments).

    As for your suggestion to using jms, I don't think there is a way to
    directly access msmq through JMS. I think there used to be support through
    hermes, but that's deprecated.

    And of course the sample code was not the code I actually want fixed. Our
    actual code calls a powershell script with multiple parameters. The script
    searches a queue based on several criteria and saves a found message on
    file. But since that script is not the problem I thought I'd give a simpler
    example with the same behaviour to not distract from what I think is the
    actual issue.